2023 Sedans Off Lease: Where the Supply Actually Is

June 18, 20265 min readCarScout
used carsbuying guide2026sedanoff-leaseHonda CivicToyota Camrymarket data

There are 2,499 used 2023 Toyota Camrys listed for sale right now. Fewer than half of them have under 50,000 miles. That's not an off-lease pool.

A 3-year lease signed in 2023 ends now. The average lessee drives 12,000 miles per year, which puts a genuine lease return around 36,000 miles, well under 50,000. Only 49% of listed 2023 Camrys are under 50,000 miles. That mileage mix fits rental turn-ins, fleet cars, and private sellers who drove a lot better than it fits lease returns, though mileage alone can't tell you a car's history.

That distinction matters more than it might seem. Off-lease vehicles are maintained under factory warranty for their entire service life, with scheduled service at dealerships. Fleet and rental cars often aren't. Knowing which category you're shopping changes what you pay, what condition to expect, and what to verify before signing.

CarScout shows 12,699 active 2023 sedan listings across six models as of June 14, 2026. The mileage mix shows which models look most consistent with lease returns. Our source counts listings in 50,000-mile bands, so the table shows the share of each model's listings under 50,000 miles rather than an exact median.

The Supply Map

Model Listings Under 50,000 miles
Toyota Camry 2,499 49%
Honda Accord 2,417 76%
Honda Civic 2,253 77%
Nissan Altima 2,158 60%
Hyundai Elantra 1,756 72%
Toyota Corolla 1,616 53%

The Civic and Accord have nearly identical mileage profiles: about three in four listings are under 50,000 miles. That fits a lease-return pool. The Camry and Corolla sit near half. The Altima sits in the middle at 60%, which suggests a mixed pool.

The Genuine Off-Lease Models

Honda Civic (2,253 listings). The 11th-gen Civic has been one of the most leased compact cars since its 2022 redesign, and those leases are maturing now. With 77% of listings under 50,000 miles, the pool is consistent with 36-month, 12,000-mile-per-year agreements. Per KBB, private-party values on a 2023 Civic run roughly $19,000 to $24,600 depending on trim and mileage. Dealers are listing above that range, but supply at 2,253 units means you've got competition leverage.

Honda Accord (2,417 listings). 76% of Accord listings are under 50,000 miles, nearly identical to the Civic. Honda's lease programs on the 2023 redesign were aggressive, and the cars are returning in volume. It markets higher than the Civic: a 2023 Accord averages $25,314 against $24,943 for a 2023 Civic (CarScout, October 25, 2026). If you want more car at a slightly higher price point, the supply is comparable to the Civic and the mileage profile is just as clean.

Hyundai Elantra (1,756 listings). The fewest listings of the three likeliest off-lease candidates, with 72% of listings under 50,000 miles. CARFAX pegs the average 2023 Elantra at $19,764, making it the entry price point in this group. More of the pool sits above 50,000 miles than with the Hondas, so filtering by mileage matters more here. Set a ceiling of 40,000 miles and the Elantra pool tightens toward likely lease returns. Fewer of them, but the price is lower and they're out there.

High-Mileage Supply: Camry, Corolla, Altima

Toyota Camry (2,499 listings). The most supply in the group, but the mileage profile doesn't support the off-lease narrative. With only 49% of listings under 50,000 miles, the mix fits fleet, rental, and high-mileage private sellers better than lease returns. That doesn't make a 2023 Camry a bad buy. The 8th-gen Camry is proven past 150,000 miles. But you're pricing and inspecting it differently than a lease return. Lease returns are likely in this pool too; mileage suggests they're a smaller share than in the Honda market. Expect to pay a premium for those.

Toyota Corolla (1,616 listings). The least supply of the six and the second-highest mileage profile. 53% of listings are under 50,000 miles. The Corolla has lower lease penetration than the Civic historically, which is why fewer genuine off-lease examples exist in this class. You'll find budget options, but those prices come with proportional mileage. If you want a 2023 Corolla, filter under 35,000 miles and expect that pool to be thin.

Nissan Altima (2,158 listings). Nissan's fleet and rental exposure is visible in the numbers. 60% of listings are under 50,000 miles. The Altima has historically high fleet/rental penetration, which is why cheap examples are common while the mileage ceiling is so high. There are deals in this pool, but the variance in condition is higher than in the Honda or Hyundai market. A full vehicle history report is non-negotiable before buying an Altima.

How to Shop This

The broad off-lease wave is real: Edmunds projects off-lease volume rising 25.7% in H2 2026, adding roughly 500,000 units to the used market compared to last year. For sedans, that supply is landing in the Civic and Accord first. The Camry and Corolla are volume leaders, but volume there is driven by fleet disposal, not lease returns.

Two different buying modes follow from that. For a Civic or Accord, you're shopping a lease-return market with real negotiating leverage and predictable condition. For a Camry or Corolla, you're shopping a value-hunting market where inspection and history verification do more work than negotiating on price.

Set up a scout on CarScout for 2023 Civics or Accords filtered under 40,000 miles. The listing count is growing as leases mature through the fall. More supply means more shots at the right car at the right price.

FAQ

Which 2023 sedan looks most like off-lease supply? The Honda Accord leads with 2,417 listings, 76% of them under 50,000 miles, followed closely by the Civic at 2,253 listings and 77%. Both profiles match 3-year, 12,000-mile-per-year leases that are maturing now. The Camry has more total listings (2,499), but fewer than half are under 50,000 miles, so the majority aren't typical lease returns.

Are 2023 Camrys worth buying used even if they're not off-lease? Yes. The 8th-gen Camry is reliable past 150,000 miles. You're buying a different vehicle than a lease return: more miles, more mileage variance, more due diligence required. Pull a full vehicle history, prioritize one-owner cars, and don't pay off-lease prices for fleet-mileage examples.

Will 2023 sedan prices drop later in 2026? Probably not much. The off-lease supply wave is pushing inventory up, but demand is holding. Per Edmunds, 58% of in-market used car shoppers say tariff-driven new car price hikes are pushing them toward used vehicles. More buyers competing for more supply keeps prices relatively stable. The opportunity is finding a clean example with favorable mileage, not waiting on a broad price drop that isn't coming.

A paid scout checks dealer inventory daily and emails a digest when new matches or price drops appear. Start with a week for $5. Cancel anytime.

Set up your search