Used Porsche Cayman 981 (2014-2016): Buyer's Guide

October 19, 202614 min readCarScout
buying guideporschecayman981

As of October 18, 2026, CarScout was tracking 88 used Porsche Cayman listings nationwide across the 2014-2016 model years, with median mileage under 50,000 miles on both 2014 and 2016 cars. Those are low miles for cars this age, so the age-related items matter more than wear.

The most important question on a 2014 or 2015 Porsche Cayman is not the engine. It is whether the rear-axle carrier recall was done. NHTSA campaign 21V679 covers 2014-2015 Cayman, Cayman S and 2015 Cayman GTS models for rear-axle carrier side sections that may fracture, and the stated consequence is loss of control. Porsche's remedy is free, but the work only happens if a car's paperwork says it did.

That recall is the exception on an otherwise well-regarded car. The 981 Cayman uses the 9A1 flat-six family, which buyer's guides from elferspot and Porsche Club GB describe as far more solid than the engines in older Caymans. The 981 is also the last Cayman with a naturally aspirated six across the whole line, from the 2.7-liter base car to the 3.8-liter GT4.

This guide covers the US-market 981 Cayman, which CarScout tracks as 2014 through 2016. It is organized by engine and trim first, then by year.

The 981 Platform: What You Are Buying

The 981 is the third-generation Cayman, a mid-engine, rear-drive two-seater with a front trunk and a rear hatch. Sources disagree on whether the platform started in 2012 or 2013 abroad. The US Cayman data is simpler: NHTSA's recall records and CarScout's records cover 2014 to 2016, and Porsche's rear-axle campaign lists 2014-2015 Cayman models, so this guide uses 2014 to 2016.

Every 981 Cayman uses a flat-six with direct injection. Elferspot's guide says the 3.4 in the S is a carry-over from the previous generation's facelifted car. Both 981 engines use direct injection.

There are four versions. The base Cayman and S arrived first. The GTS appears in CarScout's EPA records for 2015 and 2016. The GT4 appears for 2016 only, in a manual-only, track-focused car.

Powertrain Years Available HP/TQ Transmission MPG (Combined)
2.7L flat-six (Cayman) 2014-2016 275 hp / 213 lb-ft 6-speed manual or 7-speed PDK 24 manual, 25 PDK
3.4L flat-six (Cayman S) 2014-2016 325 hp / 273 lb-ft 6-speed manual or 7-speed PDK 22 manual, 24 PDK
3.4L flat-six (Cayman GTS) 2015-2016 340 hp / 280 lb-ft 6-speed manual or 7-speed PDK 22 manual, 25 PDK
3.8L flat-six (Cayman GT4) 2016 385 hp 6-speed manual only 20

Output figures come from Stuttcars and elferspot. MPG is EPA combined data as carried in CarScout's records. Some guides print slightly different horsepower numbers for the GTS and GT4, so treat the last digit as approximate and check the build sheet.

Current pricing and inventory: Porsche Cayman market data, with per-year pages for 2014, 2015 and 2016.

Engines and Known Problems

The 981 does not have a reputation for repeating failures. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide says no trending faults have been recorded on the 981, and owners across forums describe age-related wear rather than design flaws. What follows is the list of things owners and specialists do raise. Costs are labeled where they come from UK owners.

2.7L base engine (2014-2016)

The 2.7 makes 275 hp and works hard in everyday driving. A long-term owner writing for Rush Magazine put 20,000 miles on a manual 2.7 in two years, had zero regrets, and still called it short on punch for slow daily driving, with gearing that forced him to work the engine. Owners on 911uk say it is fine for most roads and that a sport exhaust helps the character.

Mechanically it shares the family traits of the S: direct injection, no IMS bearing concern and the same cooling and body issues. The same Rush owner reported a faulty alarm module, fixed with a part shared with a VW group car, and noted cold-weather quirks such as frozen side windows and fogging.

Owners on a 911uk thread warn that 2.7 cars are often poorly specified. Options such as PASM, electric seats, Bluetooth and cruise control are frequently missing. A well-equipped 2.7 is a better buy than a bare S, a point elferspot's guide makes too.

3.4L Cayman S (2014-2016)

The S makes 325 hp and is the most common 981 for sale. One buyer's guide calls it the sweet spot of the range for many buyers. Porsche Club GB posters note that well-specced S cars do not sit long on forecourts.

The engine's main worry is the direct injection system. Elferspot says injectors can leak with age, allowing fuel to wash the cylinder walls after shutdown. In rare extreme cases that can lead to bore scoring. The same guide recommends an endoscope check at purchase and at every spark plug change. Design911 and Car Checker both describe bore scoring on the 981 as rare, and note that most ownership issues are age related.

On the 981, the intermediate-shaft bearing that defined earlier Cayman reliability talk is not a concern. Renndriver says the IMS question belongs to the earlier cars, and Car Checker says the 9A1 family has no IMS bearing risk.

The recurring S-specific items are mostly bolt-ons. A UK owner of a 2014 Cayman S posted a 20-month, roughly 45,000-mile cost list on Porsche Club GB. Both headlights were replaced under warranty for a fault with the adaptive lighting, quoted at £1,300 each. Both condensers were replaced, about £1,050 for the pair. A seized auxiliary belt tensioner and bracket cost £500 and was not covered. Rear lower control arms with debonding bushes cost £636 and were not covered. Another owner on the thread said the tensioner and arm bushes came up repeatedly.

3.4L Cayman GTS (2015-2016)

The GTS keeps the 3.4 and raises output to 340 hp. Stuttcars and elferspot both list Sport Chrono and PASM as standard. Stuttcars adds sport exhaust and darker exterior trim, and Alcantara inside.

Mechanically, expect the S list above. Owners on a Porsche Club GB thread think the GTS holds value better, and say GTS cars can sit on a lot longer than a well-specced S. The more useful point for a buyer is that a GTS arrives with the options enthusiasts hunt for on an S, so you are paying for the spec as much as the power.

The GTS is also covered by 21V679. A 2015 GTS is in the campaign's vehicle list.

3.8L Cayman GT4 (2016)

The GT4 uses a 3.8-liter flat-six and a manual transmission, and no PDK was offered. A 9werks guide calls it robust with no obvious weak point, and says the main risk is the way it has been used. Track days raise the odds of over-revs from missed shifts, and of crash damage.

Owners in the Porsche Club GB forum discuss a Porsche gearbox campaign on 2016 GT4s. Per those posts and a Porsche bulletin hosted on NHTSA's site, the third-gear wheel's durability could not be guaranteed over the life of the car, with failure most likely in hard driving such as track use. The fix was a replacement manual transmission with reinforced gear wheels. This campaign does not appear in CarScout's NHTSA-sourced recall records for 2016, so do not rely on a NHTSA lookup to find it. Ask a Porsche dealer to run the VIN.

GT4 specifics from 9werks include an Alcantara steering wheel rim that mats on heavily used cars, a sport exhaust flap that can corrode or stick, and front radiators and condensers behind the bumper that take impact damage.

PDK versus manual

PDK is Porsche's dual-clutch automatic. Owners on Porsche Club GB call it very reliable. They also say dealers generally replace the unit rather than repair it, and one poster put the UK cost at £12,000 or more, which is why some owners keep an extended warranty.

Cost reports conflict. Au7o, an aggregator of owner reports, lists mechatronic position sensors as a common failure point and quotes $1,500 to $6,000 for repairs. A blog on Threepiece quotes $25,000 for a dealer replacement. Pcarwise says replacement is $20,000 or more but that the unit is repairable for far less. Treat the range as wide and get a written estimate.

One Porsche Club GB owner of a 2014 Boxster S, which shares the PDK, reported jerky shifts at about 13,500 miles with no fault codes. A technician ran a calibration drive to reset the gearbox learning, and the behavior improved. It is one report, not a pattern.

Early PDK cars lacked steering-wheel shift paddles unless the sport wheel was fitted, per elferspot. The manual is the other camp. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide puts clutch life at 50,000 to 60,000 miles and about £1,100 for the clutch in the UK, and elferspot says a heavy pedal can signal a worn clutch. A Threepiece blog gives $3,000 to $5,000 for a US clutch and flywheel job.

Problems all 981 engines and bodies share

These items come up across elferspot, Stuttcars, design911 and Porsche Club GB posters:

  • Air conditioning condensers. They sit low in the front bumper, where stone chips and debris corrode them. Two owners on Porsche Club GB had both condensers replaced, one at about six years and one under warranty. Elferspot calls the repair a four-digit sum.
  • Headlight UV coating. It can delaminate. Function is unaffected, and reconditioning costs far less than replacement.
  • Windshield sealant. It can soften and smear onto the paint. Elferspot says it is cosmetic and that there is no official recall.
  • PASM dampers. They occasionally leak.
  • Sport exhaust actuators. They can stick open or closed.
  • Bonding and leather. Door trim can lift near the window edge, and dashboard bonding can loosen, especially in sun-exposed cars.
  • Weak battery. A weak battery can throw dashboard errors. Overnight charging often clears them.

Trim Levels

The 981 sells more on spec than on badge, and owners repeatedly make that point. Elferspot says equipment and condition can matter more than the choice between the 2.7 and the S.

Trim Key Equipment What to Pay Extra For
Cayman (2.7) 275 hp, manual or PDK Pay extra for PASM, sport exhaust and the sport steering wheel with paddles. Skip bare cars.
Cayman S 325 hp, larger brakes, red calipers Pay extra for Sport Chrono, PASM and a limited-slip differential. This is the volume car.
Cayman GTS 340 hp, Sport Chrono and PASM standard Pay extra for a manual and clean options. The spec saves you hunting for equipment.
Cayman GT4 385 hp, manual only Pay for records and honest use. Ceramic brakes and carbon seats are optional extras.

Elferspot's guide calls Sport Chrono particularly worthwhile on PDK cars. It adds Sport Plus mode, dynamic transmission mounts and, on manuals, automatic throttle blipping on downshifts. Owners on Porsche Club GB and 911uk recommend a mechanical limited-slip differential and sport PASM when specifying an S.

Brakes are a spec decision. Elferspot says steel brakes can be replaced all around for under €1,000 with good parts, while ceramic replacement costs more than twice as much. On a street car, steel is the sensible pick.

Wheels matter too. Owners on 911uk advise against the 20-inch wheels for ride quality. Porsche Club GB's guide says 18-inch or 19-inch wheels ride better.

Avoid heavily modified cars. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide says aftermarket customization can be hard to resell, and Porsche Club GB posters warn that non-standard parts, such as hardwired dash cams, can complicate warranty claims.

Which Model Years to Target Within This Gen

The three model years are close mechanically. The deciding factors are recalls, trim availability and mileage. Recall counts below come from CarScout's NHTSA-sourced records for each year.

Year Recalls Key Changes Verdict
2014 4 First US year. Base and S in CarScout's EPA records. Carries 14V698000, 13V502000, 21V679000 and 19V875000 Caution: verify every campaign by VIN
2015 2 GTS arrives. Carries 14V698000 and 21V679000 Good: confirm the axle carrier work
2016 0 in CarScout's data GT4 arrives. Last 981 year Best overall

The 2014 car is the one with the longest recall list, and three of its four campaigns are narrow. Campaign 13V502000 covers certain 2014 cars built September 2 to 23, 2013, for a passenger seat wiring harness that may deactivate the front passenger airbags. Campaign 14V698000 covers certain 2014-2015 cars built May 7 to September 23, 2014, for a hood latch that may not hold. Campaign 19V875000 covers 2014 Cayman and Cayman S for child restraint instructions in the owner's manual, and the remedy is a manual supplement.

The 2016 car shows no campaign in CarScout's NHTSA-sourced data, and none of the verified generation-wide campaigns cover it. That does not mean a 2016 is perfect. The GT4 gearbox campaign sits outside that data, as covered above.

For most buyers, the 2016 Cayman S or GTS is the cleanest pick, with the 2015 GTS second once the axle recall is confirmed done. Treat a 2014 as a car you buy on paperwork.

Pre-Purchase Inspection Checklist

Every 981 should get a pre-purchase inspection from an independent Porsche specialist, with diagnostics read from Porsche's PIWIS tool. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide says PIWIS shows fault codes, over-revs and mileage discrepancies, and notes that dash mileage adjustment is not unheard of, so compare it with the engine computer's figure.

All cars

  • Read the engine management over-rev record. Elferspot's scale says categories 1 and 2 are generally uncritical, 3 and 4 need closer inspection, and 5 makes consequential damage very likely.
  • Ask for an endoscope check of the cylinders, and ask when the last one was done. Elferspot recommends one at purchase and at every spark plug change.
  • Run the VIN at the recall lookup tool. On a 2014 or 2015, ask the seller to show the completed rear-axle carrier work for campaign 21V679000. Porsche's number for it is AMB7.
  • Look behind the front bumper for condenser and radiator damage, and for corrosion.
  • Check headlights for delamination, the windshield edge for smeared sealant, and the front bumper and hood for stone chips or a repaint.
  • Cycle PASM modes, sport exhaust and every dash function, and check for sagging or lifted door trim.
  • Charge or test the battery before diagnosing any dashboard warning.
  • Check suspension for clunks and the rear lower control arm bushes for debonding.
  • Ask for service records with invoices. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide says correct servicing is a critical requirement on all 981 models.

Manual cars

  • A heavy clutch pedal can signal a worn clutch.
  • Ask whether the car was ever tracked, and read the over-rev record.

PDK cars

  • Ask for proof of a PDK fluid and filter service. Sources disagree on the interval, so you want evidence, not a number.
  • During the drive, watch for harsh shifts from cold or hesitation. Read stored faults rather than relying on a clean dash.

GT4

  • Ask a Porsche dealer to run the VIN for the third-gear gearbox campaign.
  • Check the Alcantara rim, the exhaust flap, and the front-end radiators and condensers.
  • If ceramic brakes are fitted, check the discs for cracks and chips.

Running Costs

Annual running cost estimates cluster between $1,200 and $2,500. Stuttcars cites that range, along with $1,135 from RepairPal for average annual maintenance and repair. These are estimates for typical use, not a guarantee, and one-off repairs sit on top.

Item Typical Cost Source
Minor service at a specialist About $1,200 Stuttcars
Intermediate independent service About $2,550 Stuttcars
Full-coverage insurance About $154 to $210 a month Stuttcars
Both A/C condensers About £1,050 (UK) Porsche Club GB owner
Auxiliary belt tensioner and bracket £500 (UK) Porsche Club GB owner
Rear lower control arms £636 (UK) Porsche Club GB owner
Clutch and flywheel (manual) $3,000 to $5,000 Threepiece blog
PDK repair range $1,500 to $6,000 Au7o
Fuel economy 20 to 25 mpg combined EPA via CarScout

Service intervals matter more than mileage. Porsche Club GB's guide lists a service every two years or 20,000 miles, and brake fluid every two years. Sources disagree on spark plug and PDK fluid intervals, so rely on the car's own records.

Tires carry a Porsche N-rating on the sidewall. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide says N-rated tires with at least 3 mm of tread are what to look for, and tires with good tread can still be unsafe if they are more than five years old.

Brake life depends on how it is driven. Porsche Club GB's buyer's guide gives front pad and disc life of about 25,000 miles on a 2.7 and 20,000 on an S, so budget for brakes on a car that has been driven hard.

FAQ

Is the Porsche 981 Cayman reliable? Guides and owners describe the 981 as one of the more reliable modern Porsche platforms. Porsche Club GB says no trending faults are recorded, and the 9A1 flat-six has no IMS bearing concern. Expect age-related wear: A/C condensers, headlights, tensioners and suspension bushes.

What year Cayman 981 should I avoid? Avoid buying any 2014 or 2015 on faith. CarScout's NHTSA-sourced data shows four campaigns on the 2014 and two on the 2015, including the rear-axle carrier recall 21V679000. A completed recall plus a clean inspection makes either year fine. The 2016 shows none in that data.

Is the 981 Cayman 2.7 enough, or should I buy the S? The 2.7 is adequate for road use, and owners on 911uk say it is fine for most of the year. The S is more common and has more power. Equipment matters more than the badge, so a well-specced 2.7 beats a bare S.

What is the difference between the Cayman S and GTS? The GTS has 340 hp versus the S's 325 hp, and it comes with Sport Chrono and PASM as standard. Owners on Porsche Club GB report that the cars drive similarly. The GTS is mostly a spec and value decision, and it only appears in 2015 and 2016.

Is the Cayman GT4 a reliable used car? A 9werks guide calls the 981 GT4 robust, with track use as its main risk. Check the over-rev record, borescope result and use history. Owners also discuss a Porsche gearbox campaign over third-gear durability on 2016 GT4s, so ask a Porsche dealer to run the VIN.

How many used Porsche Caymans are for sale right now? As of October 18, 2026, CarScout's market data tracked 88 used 2014-2016 Porsche Cayman listings nationwide. Current counts and per-year breakdowns are on the Porsche Cayman market page.

The Bottom Line

As of October 18, 2026, CarScout was tracking 88 used Porsche Cayman listings nationwide across the 2014-2016 model years, with median mileage under 50,000 miles on both 2014 and 2016 cars. Those are low miles for cars this age, so the age-related items matter more than wear.

The best 981 for most buyers is a 2016 Cayman S or GTS with a manual or PDK, full records and a clean endoscope report. On a 2014 or 2015, do not buy until the rear-axle carrier work for 21V679000 is documented. Run every VIN through the recall check. A CarScout scout watches dealer listings for a specific model and year range and emails you a daily digest of new matches and price drops.

Sources: NHTSA recall campaigns 13V502000, 14V698000, 19V875000 and 21V679000 from CarScout's NHTSA-sourced recall records; EPA fuel economy data as carried in CarScout's records; CarScout market data; buyer's guides from elferspot, Stuttcars, Porsche Club GB, design911, Renndriver, Car Checker, 9werks and Pcarwise; owner threads on Porsche Club GB, 911uk and 6SpeedOnline; an owner report in Rush Magazine; Au7o and Threepiece. See the full Porsche Cayman market data for pricing and inventory.

Shopping for a 2014-2016 Porsche Cayman?

CarScout checks dealer inventory daily and emails a digest when new matches or price drops appear. Start with a week for $5. Cancel anytime.

Set up a Cayman scout