2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

$353,317
avg price
17
listings
Under 50K mi
median miles
Under 50K mi94%
Fresh

Sourced from 17 dealer listings in the latest market snapshot as of

What does a used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia cost?

The average asking price is $353,317 across 17 dealer listings as of November 2026. 94% of listings have under 50,000 miles. Among 6 458 Italia model years, the 2011 averages the least ($332,795) and the 2015 the most ($433,004).

The Ferrari 458 Italia market average is $353,317. Use it as your anchor before you talk to a dealer

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Pricing

Price Trend

-1.9%
$333K$344K$356K$367K$378KOct 24Oct 25Nov 1Nov 8Nov 15$353,317
5 data pointsOct 24 – Nov 15

17 listings and counting.

Ferrari 458 Italia Safety & Reliability

Low Concern

Federal safety data shows 1 recall and 1 complaint for the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia, a low safety profile overall. Check the known issues section below for the most common problem areas.

1
Recalls
1
Complaints
0
Crashes
0
Fires
21V833000Oct 23, 2021
SERVICE BRAKES, HYDRAULIC

Ferrari North America, Inc. (Ferrari) is recalling certain 2010-2015 458 Italia, 2012-2015 458 Spider, 2014-2015 458 Speciale, 2015 458 Speciale Aperta, 2016-2019 488 GTB, and 488 Spider vehicles. The brake system may leak brake fluid, resulting in a loss of braking ability.

Loss of braking ability increases the risk of a crash.

View at NHTSA

Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)

Of 1 issues reported for the 2012 model year, fuel/propulsion system problems are the most common for the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia, with 1 complaints. A pre-purchase inspection should focus here first.

01Fuel/propulsion System1
1 total complaints for the 2012 model yearFull data at NHTSA.gov

Ferrari 458 Italia Fuel Economy

14mpg combined
·
12city
·
18hwy
·
$5,450/yr

The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is rated at 14 MPG combined across all 2 configurations. No surprises here regardless of which trim you pick.

458 Italia Coupe - Automatic (AM7)
14mpg
4.5L 8-cyl · Rear-Wheel Drive
12 city18 hwy~$5,450/yr-1/10 Poor
458 Italia Spider - Automatic (AM7)
14mpg
4.5L 8-cyl · Rear-Wheel Drive
12 city18 hwy~$5,450/yr-1/10 Poor

Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

Where to Find 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia

18States + DC

Texas has the most inventory at 19%, with options spread across 18 states.

Location counts cover all Ferrari 458 Italia model years, not just 2012.

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia: Questions Buyers Ask

How much does a 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia cost?

Budget around $353,317 for a solid 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia. Higher-mileage examples cost less, and clean, low-mile examples cost more. The pricing section has the current snapshot.

Is the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia a good car to buy?

The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia has its strengths and its watch-outs. 1 recall has been issued, so verify completion with the dealer. Owners report fuel/propulsion system as the area to watch most closely. Check the safety section for recall details and the pricing data to see if the numbers work for you.

Are there recalls on the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia?

Yes, 1 recall on record. The good news: recall repairs are always free at any authorized dealer. Check the safety report for specifics, and always run the VIN before buying.

What's the gas mileage of the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia?

The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia delivers 14 MPG combined per EPA testing. The fuel economy breakdown has city and highway numbers.

What are common problems with the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia?

Out of 1 owner complaints, fuel/propulsion system issues lead the pack with 1. Get a pre-purchase inspection that specifically covers this area. The known issues breakdown has all the details.

How does the 2012 compare to other Ferrari 458 Italia years?

Each Ferrari 458 Italia model year has different pricing, recall counts, and owner satisfaction patterns. The 2012 averages $353,317. Compare all available years on the Ferrari 458 Italia overview page.