Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium 2011

Includes:2.5i Premium
$7,146
Average Price
28
Active Listings

Sourced from 28 dealer listings in the latest market snapshot as of

Fresh

What does a used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium cost?

The average asking price is $7,146 across 28 dealer listings as of November 2026. That is $178 above the 2011 Subaru Legacy average of $6,968. Among 4 2011 Legacy trims, the 2.5i Limited averages the least ($6,054) and the 3.6R Limited the most ($9,492).

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Pricing

Price Trend

-1.3%
$7K$7K$7K$7K$8KNov 8Nov 15$7,146
2 data pointsNov 8 – Nov 15

Only 28 available nationwide.

Where to Find Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Location counts cover all Subaru Legacy model years, not just 2011.

49States + DC

The biggest cluster of inventory is in Pennsylvania (8%), but the remaining listings are spread across 48 other states nationwide.

Subaru Legacy Safety & Reliability

Safety data for all 2011 Subaru Legacy trims

Elevated

The 2011 Subaru Legacy's elevated safety profile includes 0 recall campaigns and 167 owner-reported complaints. Make recall verification part of your pre-purchase checklist.

0
Recalls
167
Complaints
7
Crashes
2
Fires

Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)

The 2011 Subaru Legacy has accumulated 167 NHTSA complaints for the 2011 model year, with power train leading the pack (37 cite it). Know what to look for before you buy.

01Power Train37
02Air Bags20
03Exterior Lighting14
04Unknown Or Other8
05Service Brakes8
167 total complaints for the 2011 model yearFull data at NHTSA.gov

Subaru Legacy Fuel Economy

EPA fuel economy data for all 2011 Subaru Legacy trims

20–25mpg combined
·
18-22city
·
24-30hwy
·
$2,450-$3,600/yr

With 4 configurations tested, the 2011 Subaru Legacy ranges from 20 to 25 MPG combined. That's a 5 MPG gap that can add up to hundreds of dollars a year in fuel costs.

Legacy AWD - Automatic (variable gear ratios)
25mpg
2.5L 4-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
22 city30 hwy~$2,450/yr-1/10 Poor
Legacy AWD - Manual 6-spd
22mpg
2.5L 4-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
19 city26 hwy~$2,800/yr-1/10 Poor
Legacy AWD - Manual 6-spd
21mpg
2.5L 4-cyl Turbo · All-Wheel Drive
18 city25 hwy~$3,600/yr-1/10 Poor
Legacy AWD - Automatic (S5)
20mpg
3.6L 6-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
18 city24 hwy~$3,100/yr-1/10 Poor

Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

2.5i Premium Trim Buyer Questions

How does the 2.5i Premium compare to other Subaru Legacy trims?

The 2.5i Premium occupies a distinct position in the Subaru Legacy range. It averages $7,146 across 28 listings. See how it stacks up on the 2011 overview page.

What should I know about maintaining the 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?

Maintenance costs for the 2.5i Premium align with the broader Subaru Legacy ownership experience, though trim-specific equipment can add to routine costs. The most-reported issue area is power train. Check the 2011 Subaru Legacy page for the full breakdown.

What are the best years for the Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?

For the 2.5i Premium, look at the price-to-mileage ratio across model years. Later model years before a redesign tend to be the most refined version of the platform. See the Subaru Legacy buyer's guide.