Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium 2016

Includes:2.5i Premium
$11,355
Average Price
63
Active Listings

Sourced from 63 dealer listings in the latest market snapshot as of

Fresh

What does a used 2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium cost?

The average asking price is $11,355 across 63 dealer listings as of November 2026. That is about the same as the 2016 Subaru Legacy average of $11,568. Among 4 2016 Legacy trims, the 2.5i averages the least ($10,476) and the 2.5i Limited the most ($12,052).

2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Pricing

Price Trend

+0.3%
$11K$11K$11K$12K$12KOct 24Oct 25Nov 1Nov 8Nov 15$11,355
5 data pointsOct 24 – Nov 15

Stop searching. Start scouting.

Where to Find Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium

Location counts cover all Subaru Legacy model years, not just 2016.

49States + DC

8% of the market sits in Pennsylvania, though listings span 49 states. Expand your search and you'll find more options at better prices.

Subaru Legacy Safety & Reliability

Safety data for all 2016 Subaru Legacy trims

Elevated

The 2016 Subaru Legacy has an elevated safety risk profile with 0 recall campaigns and 147 NHTSA complaints. Before buying, verify that all recalls have been completed. It's free at any dealer.

0
Recalls
147
Complaints
9
Crashes
0
Fires

Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)

The 2016 Subaru Legacy has 147 owner complaints for the 2016 model year. ELECTRICAL SYSTEM is the most-cited area, named in 35 of them, so ask the seller about it during your inspection.

01Electrical System35
02Unknown Or Other19
03Visibility/wiper14
04Electrical System,unknown Or Other10
05Power Train8
147 total complaints for the 2016 model yearFull data at NHTSA.gov

Subaru Legacy Fuel Economy

EPA fuel economy data for all 2016 Subaru Legacy trims

23–29mpg combined
·
20-26city
·
28-35hwy
·
$2,100-$2,650/yr

Across 2 configurations, the 2016 Subaru Legacy returns 23–29 MPG combined. Choose the thriftier option if you're commuting; the sportier setup if you're not counting gallons.

Legacy AWD - Automatic (AV-S6)
29mpg
2.5L 4-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
26 city35 hwy~$2,100/yr7/10 Clean
Legacy AWD - Automatic (AV-S6)
23mpg
3.6L 6-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
20 city28 hwy~$2,650/yr5/10 Average

Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

Is the 2.5i Premium Worth It?

How does the 2.5i Premium compare to other Subaru Legacy trims?

At $11,355 average, with 63 listings tracked, the 2.5i Premium sits in a specific spot in the 2016 Subaru Legacy lineup. Compare pricing across all trims on the 2016 Subaru Legacy page.

What should I know about maintaining the 2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?

Budget for standard 2.5i Premium maintenance plus any trim-specific items. Review the known issues on the model year page for areas to inspect before purchasing.

What are the best years for the Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium?

The best model year for the Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium comes down to the price-to-mileage ratio. Compare all years on the Subaru Legacy overview.