Toyota Highlander Plus 2016

Includes:Plus
$16,602
Average Price
34
Active Listings

Sourced from 34 dealer listings in the latest market snapshot as of

Fresh

What does a used 2016 Toyota Highlander Plus cost?

The average asking price is $16,602 across 34 dealer listings as of November 2026. That is $1,513 below the 2016 Toyota Highlander average of $18,115. A price more than 5% under the average deserves a closer look at miles, condition and service history. Among 5 2016 Highlander trims, the Plus averages the least ($16,602) and the Limited Platinum the most ($19,766).

2016 Toyota Highlander Plus Pricing

Price Trend

-0.3%
$15K$16K$16K$17K$17KOct 24Oct 25Nov 1Nov 8Nov 15$16,602
5 data pointsOct 24 – Nov 15

Only 34 available nationwide.

Where to Find Toyota Highlander Plus

Location counts cover all Toyota Highlander model years, not just 2016.

50States + DC

If you're near Texas, you're in luck: 10% of listings are there. But with 50 states represented, there's likely one near you too.

Toyota Highlander Safety & Reliability

Safety data for all 2016 Toyota Highlander trims

Elevated

With 2 recalls and 111 complaints, the 2016 Toyota Highlander rates as elevated on the safety concern scale. Always run the VIN through NHTSA's lookup tool before signing.

2
Recalls
111
Complaints
14
Crashes
1
Fires
18E107000Nov 27, 2018
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM

Fujian Wanda Automobile Glass Industry (Wanda) is recalling certain aftermarket Replacement Windshields sold for use in 2014-2018 Toyota Highlander vehicles. The windshields have an attached wire harness that water may leak into, possibly causing damage to the vehicle's Engine Control Module (ECM).

The ECM damage may result in the engine stalling, increasing the risk of a crash.

View at NHTSA
16V775000Oct 24, 2016
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM:WIRING

Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing (Toyota) is recalling certain model year 2016 Highlander vehicles manufactured May 26, 2016, to September 16, 2016. The brake fluid level sensor may not be connected to the wire harness, preventing the sensor from detecting the brake fluid level. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) No. 135, "Light Vehicle Brake Systems."

If the brake fluid level is low and is not detected, the braking performance may be decreased, increasing the risk of a crash.

View at NHTSA

Source: National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)

The 2016 Toyota Highlander's biggest weak point? UNKNOWN OR OTHER. 16 of its 111 total complaints for the 2016 model year name that area. Budget for a thorough pre-purchase inspection, especially there.

01Unknown Or Other16
02Service Brakes13
03Electrical System8
04Exterior Lighting7
05Visibility/wiper6
111 total complaints for the 2016 model yearFull data at NHTSA.gov

Toyota Highlander Fuel Economy

EPA fuel economy data for all 2016 Toyota Highlander trims

20–28mpg combined
·
18-28city
·
24-28hwy
·
$2,200-$3,100/yr

Fuel economy for the 2016 Toyota Highlander ranges from 20 to 28 MPG combined across 5 setups.

Highlander Hybrid AWD - Automatic (AV-S6)
28mpg
3.5L 6-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
27 city28 hwy~$2,200/yr7/10 Clean
Highlander Hybrid AWD LE Plus - Automatic (AV-S6)
28mpg
3.5L 6-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
28 city28 hwy~$2,200/yr7/10 Clean
Highlander 2WD - Automatic (S6)
22mpg
2.7L 4-cyl · Front-Wheel Drive
20 city25 hwy~$2,800/yr5/10 Average
Highlander 2WD - Automatic (S6)
21mpg
3.5L 6-cyl · Front-Wheel Drive
19 city25 hwy~$2,950/yr5/10 Average
Highlander AWD - Automatic (S6)
20mpg
3.5L 6-cyl · All-Wheel Drive
18 city24 hwy~$3,100/yr4/10 Average

Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

Plus Trim Buyer Questions

How does the Plus compare to other Toyota Highlander trims?

At $16,602 average, with 34 listings tracked, the Plus sits in a specific spot in the 2016 Toyota Highlander lineup. Compare pricing across all trims on the 2016 Toyota Highlander page.

What should I know about maintaining the 2016 Toyota Highlander Plus?

Budget for standard Plus maintenance plus any trim-specific items. The 2016 has 2 recalls on file. Review the known issues on the model year page for areas to inspect before purchasing.

What are the best years for the Toyota Highlander Plus?

The best model year for the Toyota Highlander Plus comes down to the price-to-mileage ratio. Compare all years on the Toyota Highlander overview.